Why the Indian Stock market tumbled down?

In last 4-5 years or so, Indian Stock Markets had been zooming up non-stop (barring the January 08 fall), crossing one milestone after another. This rise had defied law of gravity and law of average. Better economic conditions, higher GDP and greater liquidity from retail investors as well as FII were main drivers. However, during this period, good news was being given extra premium and negatives were being brushed under the carpet. Irrational exuberance and excessive greed through rationality and caution to the wind. Under such circumstances, a healthy correction was expected.

However, never-before crash (rather a vertical fall in Jan) took everyone's breathe away. Yes, global markets also turned weak but in the past, Indian markets rose even when global markets were dull. Well i feel that there is more than what meets the eye.

Repeated and aggressive media exposure to select FIIs and technical analysts appear to be the major cause for this state-of-affairs. Corporate earnings have not nosedived. Fundamentals of Indian Economy continued to be as strong (or as weak) as it was in April 2006. However, markets tanked as if Indian Economy was in the grip of 1929 type depression.

1) Finding a small ray of hope, Bears jumped into the fray who knew mentality of Indian investors that in general, investors are not so rational and act blindly upon whatever they hear or see: Came one of the respected gentleman of first flobal who said that sensex should be 10000.With due and full regards to his experience, talent and knowledge, does such a statement make any sense? 10000....??? It should be prudent to note that the same gentleman just some months back sounded as bullish as one can get. Investors, Research Analysts, Brokers stopped applying their own mind, stopped looking at fundamentals and valuations of the scrips and started singing same tune as Marc faber and the above mentioned gentleman.

2) Technical Analysts also were very successful in pulling down psyche of the investors. Strangely, when market is going up, most technical analysts predict further new highs (without any time frame). Similarly, when market is going down, most technical analysts predict further new lows (again without any time frame). I always feel the contrary and believe in rationality and law of average.

3) Normally, investors retain some liquidity. However, buoyed by the mind boggling returns, all were fully invested without any liquidity. Even many investors took leveraged positions. Instead of paying their loan installment, they took loan and invested in equity. This resulted in panic among retail investors.

So when markets crashed, F&O margin money calls came but no money. It accentuated the market fall as shares had to be sold like flood to meet margin money obligations.

4) It led to lower valuations of LAS Accounts with banks and banks were forced to sell LAS shares of their clients to keep adequate margin.

5) Many investors, in order to meet their obligations to the broker, resorted to redemption from mutual funds and fixed deposits, and more sort of stuffs were there in the offing.

6) All this led to a situation where investors, brokers were selling their shares as if they were board on a sinking ship. Its clearly proving that behaviour of investors swings wildly between bouts of irrational exuberance and irrational depression.

7) More shocking that these most respected Gurus and Institutions in one swipe rated Indian Equities as overpriced. How it can be? There may be overpriced counters which have P.E. Ratio of 20, 30 or more. But they did not bother to give devil its due which means that they should have atleast pointed out that there are still some scrips worth buying whose P.E. Ratio is less than 10 or 8 or 5 and who are going to report better results.

8) There is a saying that "Tongue hardly weighs anything but still so few people can hold it". This aptly applies to a stock tipster whose stock tips are published everyday in Business Standard. Some Examples:

Bulls go for vacation for 3-4 months.
Bears will kill the market.
Sell even now.

Same Analyst, until few days ago, was screeching from the rooftop, howling at the investors to buy so many new stocks everyday with words like "Will be 20% freeze for 3 days, 10% freeze for 5 days" etc. etc.

Conclusion:. Rationality may not be in vogue now but it would be someday........... (not assured but guaranteed)


For the first time in my life i am doing something that i am good at, in public. This blog is purely a cut-copy-paste work baring a few personal views. Their is a glut of sites, blogs, pages and views about investment & savings. Still understanding and finding the right instrument is difficult. This is an endeavor to simplify the complicated financial jargons and products to make it understood by laymen.

As the URL name suggests, it’s for laymen by a layman of finance. This blog is strictly meant for me, my family and my friends and their few friends. The blog is not meant for experts & gurus of finance.

The author of this page is not a registered financial advisor. One should not construe anything written here to be financial advice. All information is a point of view and is for educational and informational use only.